In the city of Vallejo, California, east of San Francisco, a local drama is taking place:
Cloutier is suing to be reinstated as mayor and to have the original results of the election, prior to the recount, be considered valid…
…Cloutier was sworn in as mayor on Dec. 4 after winning the machine count in the Nov. 6 election by five votes. A few days later, a manual recount revealed Davis had won by two votes; he was sworn in as mayor a week afterward.
I recently received this email (emphasis added):
The following is sent to you on behalf of Friends of Gary Cloutier:
Doing the right thing is not always easy. That is why I filed a contest to dispute the recount results in the Vallejo Mayor’s race. On Sunday, January 27, 2008 at 4 p.m. at 733 Tennessee Street in Vallejo , I intend to hold a public meeting to disclose all I know about this election and contest, and to seek funds to pay for this effort. Here’s why I have taken this action.
The day after county officials told me they had “counted every ballot”, and that I lost the election by three votes, the Registrar called my campaign manager to report that they had found a ballot marked in my favor “in the trash,” and the margin of victory was no longer three but two votes.
In a memo dated December 20, 2007, county officials advised the Board of Supervisors of an eleven vote discrepancy between the machine (under which I was sworn in as Mayor by five votes) and the hand recount. The Board was told that most “but not all” of the discrepancies could “reasonably be explained.”
The Board of Supervisors was further told that in a staff recount of the board recount in four out of the 47 Vallejo precincts, the recount was incorrect in two and that I “most likely” received one of those votes. If 2 of the 4 precincts were wrong, one has to wonder what the outcome would be if all the precincts were recounted.
We saw what happened in 2001 when the Supreme Court ordered a halt to the recount in Florida and stole the elections for the Republicans. It is time to stop bureaucrats and judges from pushing the voters around! I have advanced $26,000 to attorneys who specialize in election law to file a contest against Osby Davis who is, unfortunately, and as a result of procedure required by law, the named defendant. I am advised that the attorneys’ fees may reach $100,000 to get to the bottom of what happened in this election and to seek a fair outcome for all. That is why I need your help. You may send your donations to Friends of Gary Cloutier, Box 713 , Vallejo , California 94590 or go to: http://GARYFORMAYOR07.COM for more information or to make a donation by Pay Pal.
Thank you in advance for your help.
Very truly yours,
Gary Cloutier
Both Cloutier and Davis are liberals, although I have not been able to confirm their political party affiliations. However, consider that Vallejo voters are 60% registered Democrat (versus 17% Republican), and Solano county voters are 49% Democrat (versus 29% Republican), and it becomes difficult to substantiate claims of bias, particularly anything even remotely like ”what happened in 2001 when the Supreme Court ordered a halt to the recount in Florida and stole the elections for the Republicans.” There may, indeed, have been errors or even incompetence in the count and/or the recount (although personally I have seen no convincing evidence of that), but if this was a planned conspiracy it’s a pretty pathetic one.
Mr. Cloutier was kind enough to post the complaint for his lawsuit on his website. I note that, although Cloutier claims that his lawsuit is intended “to get to the bottom of what happened in this election and to seek a fair outcome for all,” the complaint, in fact, asks the court to declare Mr. Cloutier the lawful mayor, or, in the alternative, to annul the election and order a special election to fill the vacancy.
So here we have a liberal seeing conspiracies among other liberals to steal an election for another liberal, and still finding a way to implicate Republicans. Classic.